All articles

Business Development

Why didn't your last strategy stick?

Julia Ngapo · Published 20 Nov 2026

Before I became a coach, I ran a digital marketing agency. A business owner would come to me and say, "I want to grow. Write me a strategy that gets me out there." So I would. A beautiful, shiny one, with posts, emails, a plan for every week.

A couple of months later I'd check in. How had it gone? What had they found? More often than I'd like to admit, the answer was that they hadn't done half of it. And when I asked why, it wasn't that the plan was wrong, or that they were lazy. They were nervous about being seen.

Back then, I'd tweak the plan and hope for the best. Now I know the plan was never the problem. So if your own plan has stalled, is it really the plan?

What's going on underneath?

When a strategy stalls, it's tempting to blame time, money or the strategy itself. But often something quieter is at work. A fear of being judged. A sense that you don't have anything worth saying. That feeling of being found out, which Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes first described in 1978, in a study of high-achieving women, as the imposter phenomenon (Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice).

The fear of judgement usually overestimates how much anyone is watching. Thomas Gilovich and colleagues called this the spotlight effect: in their studies, people consistently overestimated how much others noticed them (Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2000).

I won't pretend these patterns always disappear. (Mine haven't, entirely.) But once you can see what's driving the behaviour, you can work round it rather than being run by it.

Try this:

Pick one thing from a past plan that you never got round to. Then ask yourself honestly: what was I protecting myself from? Was it being judged, not feeling I had anything worth saying, or being found out?

Name it, then choose one small version of that task you could do this week anyway.

For discussion:

  1. Think of a plan that didn't stick. Was it the plan, or something in you?
  2. Which feels most familiar: being judged, having nothing worth saying, or being found out?
  3. What's one task you keep putting off, and what might it be protecting you from?
  4. Do you notice other people's posts as much as you fear they notice yours?
  5. When did you last do the scary thing anyway, and what happened?
  6. What's one thing you'd do in your business if you knew nobody was judging?

Talk topics like this through with women who get it.

NZ Businesswomen groups meet fortnightly around New Zealand, and every meeting works through a topic like this one. Your first visit is free.